What Does It Mean to Die?

“What Does It Mean to Die?,” an article written by Rachel Aviv, chronicles the conflict between the Winkfield family and the medical staff who declared Jahi Winkfield deceased from brain-death. After a tonsil removal surgery, Jahi began coughing up blood and bleeding from her nose profusely. Her mother, Nalilah, the principal interview throughout the article, described how her daughter was not receiving proper care, which Nalilah attributes to racial discrimination. After continued neglect in the ICU, Jahi’s heart stopped, and two days later, she was declared brain-dead. She was put on a ventilator, but in California, there is a limited amount of time a hospital will allow a patient to remain in care. Due to the malpractice that had already occurred in her daughter’s care before “death,” and religious bases, Nalilah argued for her daughter’s right to remain on the ventilar and be cared for. The article offers contextual information regarding California law and insights from bioethics experts, as well as working physicians. After deciding to move to New Jersey due to their laws regarding religious-based continuation of care laws. Aviv details the controversy that emerged from this case, especially from the interest of the press and the pushback from medical professionals. Jahi continued to receive care from nurses and remained on a ventilator. Nalilah, her family, and some medical professionals believe that Jahi still is not “dead;” Jahi has physical responses, menstruates, and has a lowered heart rate at the sound of her mother’s voice. These facts prove, for some, as evidence for her right to care. However, some argue that this could be a shared delusion in the family. Regardless, the article presents many perspectives that ask the audience to understand the situation from different sides, while still staying grounded in Jahi’s story and Nalilah’s fight for care. 

This story could be used in discussions of modern-day bioethics, especially in discussion of continued discrimination of BIPOC patients and families. Furthermore, it could lead to a discussion about the right to care and how we define “death” in different contexts. 

Access